Now Reading
Cursed Lord Street scheme returns to planners amid row over ‘profit-trigger’ affordable housing payments

Cursed Lord Street scheme returns to planners amid row over ‘profit-trigger’ affordable housing payments

Screenshot 2026 02 25
  • Planning officer still recommends refusal.
  • New application goes back to committee on Monday
  • 12-storey tower (down from 14), cinema and 85 flats proposed for former bus station site
  • Developer wants affordable housing and open space payments only if returns hit 20%
  • Cap of £1.574m suggested – but critics say the structure makes policy optional
  • Planning officers propose a tougher trigger from 17.5% with staged payments into commuted sums
  • Grant shadow: viability claim made while a £15.8m public funding route sits in the background

A multi-million-pound redevelopment of Douglas’s former Lord Street bus station site is due back before the Isle of Man planning committee next week.

Officials are still recommending outright refusal of the new scheme, and fresh scrutiny on a proposal that would make affordable housing contributions conditional on profit.

But the revised scheme by Lord Street Development SPV has already sparked a backlash, with one Douglas businessman describing it as ‘wheeze’ to squeeze a £15 million profit from the already under-fire government.

Screenshot 2026 03 12 at 15.37.52

He told Expose.News: ‘It’s a try-on by the developers.

‘Not only is there no guaranteed affordable housing –  which is against government policy – but the developers want a £15 million Infrastructure grant to cover their profit.

‘Now, in their latest ruse, they are using affordable housing as a bargaining chip in this new sliding scale, which the planners have been forced to come up with.

Screenshot 2026 02 25
Revised plans for Lord Street (Lord Street Development SPV Ltd)

‘It’s cherry picking which policies you go along with, but it’s a good job that the dissenting planning officer is sticking to his guns.’

The new proposal includes a multi-screen cinema, 85 apartments and a 12-storey tower block (reduced from 14). 

The design also includes transport facilities, including bus stands and passenger waiting areas.

Last week the committee rejected an officer recommendation to refuse the application on the chairman’s casting vote.

Expose.News ran a story in which Douglas Council leader Devon Watson made the case for affordable housing.

Devon Watson

But a final decision has been delayed to allow members and the applicant to negotiate conditions. 

The central objection remains: the project contains no on-site affordable housing and no public open space.

The most recent argument now centres on a ‘review mechanism’ for commuted sums. 

The applicant’s model would require payments towards affordable housing and public open space only if the development achieves a 20% return.

Even then, the combined total would be capped at £1.574m.

Planning officers have proposed a stricter three-stage approach, starting earlier at 17.5% return.

The plan includes staged payments that prioritise affordable housing first and then public open space, up to £1,100,750 and £473,175 respectively (a combined £1,573,925).

Objectors say the profit-trigger model risks turning affordability into an optional add-on rather than a policy requirement. 

One objector has called the approach contrary to policy and ‘untenable’.

The planning officer has indicated a review mechanism could be considered only in the exceptional context of this site, described as a brownfield regeneration project with ‘significant public benefit’. 

He has warned it would be ‘highly unlikely’ to be accepted elsewhere.

The developer argues that without the proposed mechanism the scheme would not be financially workable. 

But the planning report also notes the case is being made despite the prospect that up to £15.8m in government support could be available through the Island Infrastructure Scheme.

Housing campaigner Devon Watson says new developments are a test of whether the Island’s affordable housing ambitions survive contact with flagship regeneration schemes. 

‘Housing is completely unaffordable,’ he says, warning that ‘a lot of young people are leaving… because housing is completely unaffordable…..

See Also
5630ad38 bd98 4781 9eb7 694a5d53e9ee

‘…….We all deserve that basic human right of shelter…..

‘………You can’t really start a family’ — and you can’t upsize or downsize when prices spiral……’

He warned that resentment grows when wages stagnate and rents ‘buy someone else a house’

‘….when housing is unaffordable, it becomes very difficult to move back….

‘But if housing’s unaffordable and there’s nowhere for people to move back to, then that process of people coming back to raise kids just doesn’t happen….

‘…….if you’re middle class and you can’t afford decent housing, you can’t afford to buy a home, then you can’t really start a family….

‘If you’re already have a family and you want to grow your family, you can’t do so because you can’t afford to upsize.’

‘it’s very difficult to downsize when housing prices are through the roof.’

Campaigners also say the politics are being inflamed by the wider ‘Double L’ mood: Lord Street on one side, and the Liverpool ferry terminal cost saga on the other – controversies that have hardened public suspicion about who carries risk when big numbers and public money appear in the same sentence.

Screenshot 2025 02 03 at 22.06.53

The unrelated £90 Million Lord Street case is still ongoing, which involved the previous developers Sondica Group, which initially won the bid then had their contract cancelled.

Sondica is now claiming malfeasance and corruption were involved when a so-called independent report by consultants Lambert Smith Hampton was allegedly altered to their disadvantage. 

The committee’s task on Monday is to decide whether the mechanism is a pragmatic route to unlock development, or a precedent that lets developers meet policy in theory while structuring payments so they arise only if profit targets are met.

© 2021. All Rights Reserved.

Scroll To Top