Now Reading
LSH LANDS £500,000 COUNCIL DEAL AS IT FIGHTS TO EXIT £90M CASE

LSH LANDS £500,000 COUNCIL DEAL AS IT FIGHTS TO EXIT £90M CASE

D3884f9f 799d 48c6 996e 6fd3bb7628ca (1)
Changing skyline, Birmingham city centre geograph.org.uk
Birmingham city centre’s changing skyline, as the council signs a new contract with Lambert Smith Hampton. Photo: Michael Westley, licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
  • Birmingham hires LSH to provide independent scrutiny of developers’ financial appraisals
  • Meanwhile, on the Isle of Man Sondica opposes the firm’s bid to leave the Lord Street litigation before a full trial
  • An adverse finding could put LSH’s public-sector reputation under scrutiny far beyond the UK independent territory
  • Key events are happening in the same month…
  • LSH are believed to have signed with Birmingham on October 1
  • But just over a week later, the company will submit important defence documents to the High Court

LAMBERT Smith Hampton has secured a new Birmingham City Council contract worth up to £500,000 – while fighting to leave the Isle of Man’s £90 million Lord Street litigation before a full trial.

Birmingham is buying independent professional scrutiny of developers’ financial appraisals from the controversial property consultants.

In the £90 Million Lord Street case, Sondica is challenging a similar form of advice, specifically how LSH’s professional opinion to a public-sector client changed.

Sondica says LSH initially identified its proposal as the best bid and recommended that it proceed.

Approximately a week later, the Douglas-based firm says, a second recommendation criticised the bid and advised against awarding a contract.

The developer alleges intervention by a government official between those assessments.

LSH and the Government defendants deny wrongdoing, and the court has yet to make a finding that LSH acted improperly.

Deemster Corlett, the judge in the long-running case, has stressed that Sondica’s misfeasance-in-public-office allegation concerns the government official, rather than LSH.

Sondica nevertheless says LSH is a critical witness to what happened.

Meanwhile, 160 miles away in Birmingham, LSH’s new contract covers financial viability assessments for residential, commercial and mixed-use planning applications and appeals.

The work may also involve pre-application advice and appearances as an expert witness.

The published contract value is £500,000 excluding VAT, with the four-year term due to run from 1 December 2026 to 30 November 2030. Actual spending will depend on the work commissioned.

The latest published notice gives 1 October as the estimated signing date.

There is no suggestion Birmingham acted improperly in making the award.

The council is an established LSH client.

The firm already holds the outgoing viability-assessment contract and sits on Birmingham’s wider Property and Land Full Valuation Service Panel, whose work supports the council’s asset-disposal programme.

An industry source familiar with LSH’s wider public sector work told Expose.News: “There’s obviously a reputational risk for LSH.”

LSH wants the Manx court to decide whether it owed Sondica a legal duty before a full evidential trial. Its lawyers argue that the firm was retained by Government and owed its professional obligations to that client.

See Also
SONY DSC

If that argument succeeds, the damages claim against LSH could end without the court determining every factual allegation about the tender.

Sondica opposes that approach. It argues that LSH’s conduct forms part of the disputed factual background to its wider case against Government and cannot safely be separated from it.

The parties are due to file skeleton arguments on 9 October over whether preliminary legal issues should be determined before a full trial.

A contested hearing could follow in November.

The filing deadline itself will decide neither liability nor the disputed facts.

An adverse finding on LSH’s professional conduct could prompt public-sector clients to reassess their confidence in its advice.

As the industry source put it: “LSH earns public-sector work by selling professional judgement, valuation expertise and independent advice.

“But if Lord Street ever produces a reasoned judgment addressing LSH’s professional conduct, councils far beyond Douglas may suddenly have reason to read it.”

ENDS

© 2021. All Rights Reserved.

Scroll To Top