Now Reading
‘WE JUST WANT OUT’: LSH PUSHES TO AVOID FULL TRIAL COSTS IN LONG-RUNNING £90 MILLION LORD STREET BATTLE

‘WE JUST WANT OUT’: LSH PUSHES TO AVOID FULL TRIAL COSTS IN LONG-RUNNING £90 MILLION LORD STREET BATTLE

Close up of Lady Justice statue holding scales, symbolizing justice and fairness
Isle of Man Courts of Justice building, Douglas
The Isle of Man Courts of Justice in Douglas, where Deemster Corlett is hearing the £90 million Lord Street case. Photo: Karan Kamath, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.
  • LSH says the company should not have to incur expert and full trial costs
  • The property firm wants no further expenditure before the court decides whether any legal duty was owed to Sondica
  • The consultancy may revive a strike-out application
  • If the preliminary-issues route does not provide a speedy determination of the claim against it
  • Deemster Corlett described the overall delay in the litigation as “appalling”
  • But did not make a finding that any single party was responsible

Isle of Man government consultants Lambert Smith Hampton has told the High Court that it wants the claim against it resolved.

The property group — which is owned by the Skipton Building Society — said it wants extrication from the controversial £90 million Lord Street case before costs spiral.

Substantial expenditure will be incurred preparing expert evidence for a full Lord Street trial, the court heard.

So the surveying business is pressing for an early determination on a matter of law.

The question is whether the bidding procedure advisors owed any duty of care to claimant Sondica Group Inc during the disputed tender process.

LSH says it did not.

The company’s advocate, Mrs Corkish, told Deemster Corlett that the consultancy’s overriding priority was to secure a determination of the claim against it.

Either through preliminary legal issues or, if necessary, through a strike-out application.

The argument came during a September 3 hearing dominated by disagreement over the most efficient route through litigation arising from events dating back to 2015.

Wells Street, London W1 geograph.org.uk
Wells Street, London W1, home to Lambert Smith Hampton’s head office. Photo: Derek Harper, licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

The scale of the delay drew unusually strong criticism from the bench.

Deemster Corlett said: “This case, it’s appalling the amount of time it’s taking.”

He noted that it was “very unusual” for the court itself to write to parties asking what was happening in a case.

But such an intervention had occurred here.

The remark was directed at the progress of the litigation as a whole, rather than a finding that any single party was responsible for the delay.

Against that background, LSH says there is no justification for taking every issue immediately to a full trial.

Mrs Corkish said the consultancy had previously prepared a proposed strike-out application on the basis that Sondica’s pleadings disclosed no reasonable grounds for a tortious claim against LSH.

That draft was sent in the hope, she said, that the claim against LSH might be withdrawn without the need for the application to be formally made.

Later, the first and second defendants – the Department of Infrastructure and Treasury – proposed dealing with preliminary issues, an approach which LSH considered potentially useful because some of the same legal questions arise in the claims against all three defendants.

LSH’s case is that its contractual duty was to its client and that it did not owe an independent duty to Sondica, which had participated in the tender process.

Mrs Corkish told the court that determining that question first could prevent money being spent unnecessarily.

“Certainly, we don’t want to be spending costs on obtaining expert evidence, etc, if in fact, as a matter of law, there cannot be a claim, as we say, against the third defendant,” she said.

Deemster Corlett appeared to recognise the significance of that argument, while repeatedly stressing that he had not yet heard the full contested application.

He observed that the position regarding LSH might be capable of being disposed of by way of preliminary issue.

LSH argued that questions such as the existence and scope of any duty of care could largely be determined from the pleaded case, the retainer and agreed facts rather than extensive oral testimony.

Mrs Corkish said there was no direct relationship between Sondica and LSH before the tenders were submitted and maintained that relatively few documents should be required to determine the legal issue.

Sondica disputes that analysis.

Its advocate, Mrs Vicky Unsworth, argued that the case is not simply a document-based dispute and said live evidence would be necessary.

She warned that splitting the litigation into preliminary issues followed by a later trial risked fragmenting the proceedings, duplicating evidence and ultimately increasing both delay and costs.

See Also
D3884f9f 799d 48c6 996e 6fd3bb7628ca (1)

Sondica also says LSH is intimately connected to the factual sequence underlying one of the most serious elements of its case.

The claimant relies on what it says was an initial LSH recommendation that Sondica was the best bid.

But the positive direction was followed around a week later by a different letter which, according to Sondica, made allegations against it and recommended that it should not proceed.

The claimant alleges misfeasant government intervention in the period between those documents.

Deemster Corlett emphasised that the allegation of misfeasance in public office concerns the government individual identified in Sondica’s case, rather than LSH itself.

Mrs Unsworth nevertheless maintained that LSH would remain a critical witness even if the legal claim against the consultancy were removed.

LSH countered that being a witness is entirely different from remaining a defendant required to obtain expert evidence and defend itself throughout a full trial.

Mrs Corkish went further, telling the court that if the preliminary-issues route did not provide a speedy resolution for LSH, the consultancy might revert to a strike-out application.

“It doesn’t really matter to us how we extract ourselves, whether it’s by prelim or strike-out,” she said.

No decision was made on whether LSH should leave the proceedings.

Deemster Corlett directed instead that the contested preliminary-issues application be argued properly with written submissions and authorities.

The parties must file skeleton arguments by October 9 and an agreed bundle by October 16, with a hearing expected potentially in November.

For LSH, that hearing could become a pivotal moment: either opening an early route out of the litigation or leaving the consultancy facing the prospect of continuing towards the much larger trial Sondica is seeking.

ENDS

© 2021. All Rights Reserved.

Scroll To Top